People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Good and fresh most times but i feel they keep it to long in the warmer and ends up hard and not good. Warmer life should be decreased by 40 min id say. ”
“ Outstanding service and great pizza! I am saving some for tomorrow lunch! The White sauce and The Red Sauce was secretly placed in different places of my pizza. It was super awesome as it made every bite different from the other. The breadsticks and pizza crust was soft and baked fresh. The staff were very enthusiastic and ready to serve. Great northeast pizza experience ”
“ Friendly staff, clean restaurant, great breadsticks and pizza. Was pleasantly surprised at just how good it was. This location was also interesting because they incorporated the areas rich history into the photography, newspaper articles, and sponsored groups celebrated on their walls demonstrating strong community ties. Will definitely be back next time I'm in the area. ”
“ The pizza here is super good and the service was amazing! We were just driving through town and decided to give it a shot, well worth it. We got some supreme, chicken Buffalo and chicken bacon ranch. They tasted so good! ”
“ We had a great time with our family. We ordered two large pizzas, and it was more than our family of 6 needed. We ordered a thin crust pepperoni. It was outstanding! A great New york style pizza. We also got standard meat lovers. It was thick and huge, heavy on the meat. Highly recommended! ”
“ Had lunch on my break. With a couple of cheese slices and a order of medium bone in wings. The service was good and recommend I would definitely come back when I am in the area. ”
“ Absolutely the best Supreme pizza anywhere. Choice toppings and a great crust. ”
“ I've known Mark's Pizzeria since the beginning in the 1980s in Palmyra, NY. The pizza was great then and it's still fantastic... with even more choices. I've grown up on Mark's Pizza and I love it! ”
Menu
Orange Crush
US$3.05Honey Stung Pizza
US$21.99Buffalo Blue Cheese Chicken Pizza
US$21.99Spicy Ranch Chicken Pizza
US$21.99New York Style Pizza
US$17.59
About
Mark's Pizzeria Palmyra
Welcome to Mark's Pizzeria Palmyra, your go-to destination for pizza enthusiasts in Palmyra, NY! Located at 240 E Main St, this charming pizzeria encapsulates the essence of New York-style pizza, delivering delicious flavors paired with a warm, welcoming atmosphere.
As you step inside, the first thing that catches your eye is the vibrant display of local history adorning the walls, from vintage photographs to community-sponsored articles. This attention to detail not only reflects the rich cultural tapestry of Palmyra but also underlines Mark's commitment to community engagement.
When it comes to their pizza, the reviews speak volumes. Customers rave about the White sauce and Red sauce, artfully crafted to provide a unique tasting experience in every bite. Terry Barber was particularly impressed, noting how the sauces made each slice an adventure of flavor. The freshly baked crust and soft breadsticks complement the pizzas perfectly, making for an outstanding meal that leaves you craving more.
Notably, the combination of customer service and high-quality ingredients sets Mark's Pizzeria apart. The enthusiastic staff is dedicated to providing an enjoyable dining experience, as highlighted by Victor Domine's review of their friendly demeanor and the cleanliness of the establishment. It's clear that each visit is not just about the food, but also about the connection with the community and its people.
For families, Mark's offers generous pizza sizes that cater to every need. David Edwards' experience with large pizzas proved more than sufficient for his family of six, showcasing the restaurant's ability to satisfy hungry appetites. The thin crust pepperoni and hearty meat lovers options are just a glimpse into the variety available, ensuring that everyone leaves with a full belly and a smile.
So, whether you’re just driving through or a local resident, make sure to stop by Mark's Pizzeria Palmyra. Indulge in their delicious pizzas and experience the delightful harmony of flavors, all while enjoying the unmatched hospitality of a community-driven establishment. You won’t be disappointed!
Contact them at +1 315-597-2727 for takeout or to learn more about their menu offerings!
Book a table